On Simplicity and Scripture: Struggling with the Word

One thing I’ve noticed over the years of being involved and associated with different ministries and programs is this: we seem to crave simplicity. Not that I have a problem with simplicity, it’s just that, in certain contexts, it becomes dangerous.

Let me explain via a couple of scenarios that I find quite common:

  1. I attend a church service in which the preacher’s text is a single verse. And from that verse, the speaker (who is usually quite gifted), paints a beautiful and complete picture of the Christian life. He points out things I have never seen, he reveals things hidden in the original text (because the rough accent mark is used, this word is inverted, giving the word a completely different meaning, etc) Life is g0od. I am enlightened. Until a few days later I try to explain my new-found knowledge to a friend. Questions are raised. The puzzle pieces which fit together so neatly a few days ago now have imperfect edges. I explain that I must have missed some of the points. I assure my friend, the fault must lie with me.
  2. I come across a difficult passage in scripture. I re-read it. I re-re-read it. I consult Strong’s for each word in the passge, including “the“. I check different translations. Finally, I stumble across a translation that abstracts away enough of the text that I make some sort of sense out of it. I am elated. I mark the verse down as “Assimilated” in my Conquer the Bible Diary.
  3. My wife asks me a question about a verse or a passage of Scripture. I begin answering her as best I can. My answer is incomplete and only raises more questions (But if that is true, then wouldn’t that mean…). I grow exasperated. She becomes frustrated. I finally answer the question with an answer to this effect: Well it sort of works like this, blah, blah, and somehow works together with blah, blah, and I’ll look into it and get back to you. I never exactly get around to answering the question.

I hope you can see the common thread that runs through each of these examples.

  1. A speaker takes a single verse and builds a system around it.
  2. I, in my desire to “understand” God, am willing to trade away his word.
  3. I, in my desire to end my wife’s questioning or to get back the television show I am watching or to avoid having to change my life due to the implications of Scripture, simplify the word of God, and in so doing, show contempt for it’s authority

This is where I see the danger in desiring simplicity. God did not give us a single verse, he gave us his complete word. God did not give us 500 translations to pick and choose from, there are good ones and there are bad ones, and we are to seek HIS meaning, not the verson that is simplest or the most expedient or the most culturally correct. God did not say that every verse would take five minutes to explain, he did not say that his teachings would fit in an email tag line or on a T-shirt. We are to struggle with the word, we are to wrestle with his meaning. No single verse can give us a complete understanding of God. No ten minutes of study will equip us for life’s battles. No man-created system can ever replace a dynamic relationship with Him.

This entry was posted in Christianity and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://timbob.wordpress.com/ timbob

    Acts 17:11, II Timothy 2:15 and II Timthy 3:16 come to mind here. It is ever so important to make sure that we’re following God and not another person. While the Lord does give us pastors, teachers, evangelists and the like, we each must prayerfully study the word of God knowing that it’s from him that true understanding comes from. You are accurate in your post. Also Jeremiah 33:3 comes to mind.

  • http://timbob.wordpress.com/ timbob

    Acts 17:11, II Timothy 2:15 and II Timthy 3:16 come to mind here. It is ever so important to make sure that we’re following God and not another person. While the Lord does give us pastors, teachers, evangelists and the like, we each must prayerfully study the word of God knowing that it’s from him that true understanding comes from. You are accurate in your post. Also Jeremiah 33:3 comes to mind.

  • http://gymbrall.wordpress.com/ gymbrall

    timbob,
    Thanks for the comment and the references. I think man by his very nature likes systems, but when we believe that we can systematize the Word of God, we fall prey to our own pride. By this I don’t mean that God is not systematic, just that we cannot construct a system to contain Him as we are within the system. I hope that makes sense… re-reading my own stuff… hmmm…. I think it’s ok…
    Anyway, thanks for stopping by,
    Charles

  • http://gymbrall.wordpress.com/ gymbrall

    timbob,
    Thanks for the comment and the references. I think man by his very nature likes systems, but when we believe that we can systematize the Word of God, we fall prey to our own pride. By this I don’t mean that God is not systematic, just that we cannot construct a system to contain Him as we are within the system. I hope that makes sense… re-reading my own stuff… hmmm…. I think it’s ok…
    Anyway, thanks for stopping by,
    Charles

  • http://iambicadmonit.blogspot.com Admonit

    I really appreciate these thoughts. I find them relevant & accurate. Simplicity is good if it means, perhaps, things like: unity, holism, narrative clarity, thorough usefulness, elimination of clutter, etc. But not when it means taking the easy way out. I had a Hebrew prof. in undergrad who used to say, appropos of the Scripture, “A text without a context is a pretext.” So too can be our interpretations. But I don’t think that means those of us who have had good Biblical training should be afraid to interpret Scripture according to principles we’ve already laid down, or to go with what seems the most obvious & natural & traditional reading sometimes. Do you?

  • http://iambicadmonit.blogspot.com Admonit

    I really appreciate these thoughts. I find them relevant & accurate. Simplicity is good if it means, perhaps, things like: unity, holism, narrative clarity, thorough usefulness, elimination of clutter, etc. But not when it means taking the easy way out. I had a Hebrew prof. in undergrad who used to say, appropos of the Scripture, “A text without a context is a pretext.” So too can be our interpretations. But I don’t think that means those of us who have had good Biblical training should be afraid to interpret Scripture according to principles we’ve already laid down, or to go with what seems the most obvious & natural & traditional reading sometimes. Do you?

  • http://gymbrall.wordpress.com/ gymbrall

    Hi Admonit,
    Thanks for dropping by and thanks for leaving a comment. They are always appreciated.

    Regarding your question:
    But I don’t think that means those of us who have had good Biblical training should be afraid to interpret Scripture according to principles we’ve already laid down, or to go with what seems the most obvious & natural & traditional reading sometimes. Do you?

    No. But I do think we should constantly challenge our presuppositions. And I think the way that we do that is by challenging them with more Scripture. I think there is a tendency today to read a verse and to say, but wait Scripture says this over here, I guess I should just ignore one of these passages(See my post on predestination and free will for an example of this.
    Scripture makes us realize that life isn’t as neat as we’d like it to be. Men and Women are equal in their relationship with God, but not equal in function (we don’t do the exact same things – physically or spiritually), God has ordained all things, but men have choice, God is three, but he’s also One, Christ is equal with God, but he submits to the Father’s will, it’s not neat, it’s not tidy, it’s complicated and it’s wonderful.

  • http://gymbrall.wordpress.com/ gymbrall

    Hi Admonit,
    Thanks for dropping by and thanks for leaving a comment. They are always appreciated.

    Regarding your question:
    But I don’t think that means those of us who have had good Biblical training should be afraid to interpret Scripture according to principles we’ve already laid down, or to go with what seems the most obvious & natural & traditional reading sometimes. Do you?

    No. But I do think we should constantly challenge our presuppositions. And I think the way that we do that is by challenging them with more Scripture. I think there is a tendency today to read a verse and to say, but wait Scripture says this over here, I guess I should just ignore one of these passages(See my post on predestination and free will for an example of this.
    Scripture makes us realize that life isn’t as neat as we’d like it to be. Men and Women are equal in their relationship with God, but not equal in function (we don’t do the exact same things – physically or spiritually), God has ordained all things, but men have choice, God is three, but he’s also One, Christ is equal with God, but he submits to the Father’s will, it’s not neat, it’s not tidy, it’s complicated and it’s wonderful.

  • http://bittersweetblue.blogspot.com Ariel

    The tension between simplicity (child-like faith) and complexity (mysterious revelation) in Christianity is one that doesn’t really go away… I appreciate the central theme of your post a great deal. It’s a shame when a verse becomes a platform for someone’s personal agenda.

    However…after scanning several translations for one that suited my purpose, I did find THIS:

    We teach in a spirit of profound common sense so that we can bring each person to maturity. To be mature is to be basic. Christ! No more, no less.
    – Colossians 1:28, The Message
    ;)

  • http://bittersweetblue.blogspot.com Ariel

    The tension between simplicity (child-like faith) and complexity (mysterious revelation) in Christianity is one that doesn’t really go away… I appreciate the central theme of your post a great deal. It’s a shame when a verse becomes a platform for someone’s personal agenda.

    However…after scanning several translations for one that suited my purpose, I did find THIS:

    We teach in a spirit of profound common sense so that we can bring each person to maturity. To be mature is to be basic. Christ! No more, no less.
    – Colossians 1:28, The Message
    ;)

  • http://gymbrall.wordpress.com/ gymbrall

    Ariel,
    But you see, I have through much wisdom and prayer and skill with an X-acto knife, removed Colossians from my Bible. So, problem solved. And Eugene Peterson is next… MUWAHAHAHA!!!!

  • http://gymbrall.wordpress.com/ gymbrall

    Ariel,
    But you see, I have through much wisdom and prayer and skill with an X-acto knife, removed Colossians from my Bible. So, problem solved. And Eugene Peterson is next… MUWAHAHAHA!!!!

  • http://www.bhotels.info Florian

    Hi,
    I found your blog via google by accident and have to admit that youve a really interesting blog :-)
    Just saved your feed in my reader, have a nice day :)

  • http://www.bhotels.info Florian

    Hi,
    I found your blog via google by accident and have to admit that youve a really interesting blog :-)
    Just saved your feed in my reader, have a nice day :)